Hinson, Gravelle & Adair
Telephone: (661) 294-0111

The Tucson Herpetological Society v. Salazar Decision And Its Progeny: A Move Away From Blind Deference To Agency Decision-Making

June 26, 2012 by Eric Adair in News with 0 Comments

Hinson Gravelle & Adair LLP partner Eric Adair recently published a paper in the March 2012 California Water Law & Policy Reporter, in collaboration with Rebecca Akroyd of Kronick Moskovitz Tiedemann & Girard. The paper discusses a 2009 Ninth Circuit decision, Tucson Herpetological Society v. Salazar, 566 F.3d 870 (9th Cir. 2009), and its progeny. From the introduction to the paper:

With its 2009 decision in Tucson Herpetological Society v. Salazar, 566 F.3d 870 (9th Cir. 2009), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit signaled that courts should not blindly defer to scientific decisions made by federal agencies when those agencies fail to adequately explain or justify those decisions. The significant deference afforded federal agencies notwithstanding, Tucson Herpetological established a judicial willingness to look behind the decision-making process to ensure that agency decisions are consistent with and supported by the best available science.

In the three years since Tucson Herpetological, courts have taken this direction seriously. Six recent Administrative Procedure Act (APA) cases reflect a new trend in case law that gives teeth to the concept that federal agencies must explain their scientific decisions regarding endangered or threatened species. These cases confirm a move away from blind deference to agency decisions and a move toward transparency. In this article, we consider the implications of recent jurisprudence on this topic, particularly for resources users who are in the position of challenging federal agency decision making pertaining to listed species.

To continue reading the paper, please click here.

For more information regarding this matter, please contact Eric Adair. Follow Eric on Twitter: .

Tagged → , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


Contact Hinson Gravelle & Adair LLP

27240 Turnberrry Lane, Suite 200
Valencia, California 91355

Office: (661) 294-0111


This website is intended as an advertisement only in California and Hawaii, and not any other state. Hinson Gravelle & Adair LLP does not seek to represent any person or entity based solely on that person’s or entity’s visit to this website. Any information submitted to Hinson Gravelle & Adair LLP through this website will not be confidential. The use of this website, including unsolicited e-mail, does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and Hinson Gravelle & Adair LLP. Nothing in this website is intended to be legal advice. Do not rely upon any information provided in this website or in any links provided herein in lieu of a consultation with an attorney.